Yankees’ Qualifying Offer Decision Points to Chisholm Exit

The Yankees’ decision not to extend a qualifying offer to Jazz Chisholm has added to expectations that the infielder will leave the team. New York did offer closer David Bednar $23.15 million on November 2. The moves followed a difficult 2026 season for Chisholm, whose performance fell short of expectations, and a return to the Yankees as a free agent now appears unlikely. The team could still re-sign him.

Chisholm has said he wants to stay in New York. After the Yankees’ loss in the American League Division Series, he said, “This is where I want to be.” The Yankees were swept by the Rays, and Chisholm faced boos from fans during the series. He said the reaction confused him because he was trying to help the team win, while noting that Aaron Judge had also been booed in the Bronx.

Former major league general manager Jim Bowden said he would favor younger, more consistent players over Chisholm, citing what he characterized as baggage and concerns about consistency. Chisholm’s athletic ability has stood out at times, but inconsistency and concentration issues have also been raised. If the Yankees do not bring him back, he could look for a short-term contract elsewhere.