Rookie Grades Show Standouts and Struggles After Eight NFL Weeks

Eight weeks into the NFL season, Arvell Reese and Sonny Styles have emerged as two of the class’s top performers. Both linebackers received A+ grades: Reese has made an immediate impact for the Giants, while Washington has already trusted Styles to communicate defensive calls before the snap. Styles has excelled in coverage and improved against the run, though missed tackles remain a concern.

Jets edge rusher David Bailey earned a B after a slow start gave way to a three-sack game against Cleveland. Chiefs cornerback Mansoor Delane received an A-, with health his main concern, and Browns tackle Spencer Fano also earned an A- after adapting to left tackle. Titans receiver Carnell Tate’s reliable play earned him a B.

Several players’ grades reflect unfinished business. Raiders quarterback Fernando Mendoza remains behind Kirk Cousins and received an incomplete after a brief appearance against New England. Cardinals running back Jeremiyah Love, graded C+, has been limited by an ankle injury. Saints receiver Jordyn Tyson also received an incomplete amid ongoing health problems. Giants guard Francis Mauigoa and Cowboys safety Caleb Downs each earned a C+; Downs has struggled after a strong start, with rivals completing 20 of 24 throws directed his way, gaining 230 yards and scoring three touchdowns. Ten rookies selected after the first round are also graded, though details of their evaluations are unavailable.